ClinicClaim Underpaid Claim Recovery
Updated November 2026

The IDR Guide for
out-of-network providers

How to recover underpaid insurance claims through Federal IDR and Florida §408.7057: the deadlines, who qualifies, what the data shows, and how to pick the right forum.

The Basics

What is Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR)?

Short answer: IDR is binding arbitration, created by the federal No Surprises Act (2022), that lets an out-of-network provider challenge an underpaid insurance claim. The provider and the insurer each submit one final offer, and a neutral, CMS-certified arbitrator picks one of the two.

Before the No Surprises Act, an out-of-network provider could balance-bill the patient. The law took the patient out of the middle for covered services and gave providers arbitration instead. Insurers set the opening payment, often 7–10% of billed charges, and most providers never challenge it. More than 90% of eligible claims go unfiled.

Florida providers have a second path: the state claim dispute program under Florida Statute §408.7057. Which path applies depends on the plan and the service, and choosing wrong can cost you the claim.

Federal

Federal IDR under the No Surprises Act

What's covered

Which plans

Most group health plans, including self-insured ERISA plans, individual (ACA marketplace) coverage, and Federal Employees Health Benefits plans. Not eligible: Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, VA and Indian Health Service, which have their own processes. Where a state law like Florida's applies to a state-regulated plan, that state process may govern instead.

How the arbitrator decides

It's "baseball-style": one offer from each side, and the arbitrator must choose one. There's no splitting the difference. The arbitrator considers the QPA along with credible additional information, such as the provider's training and experience, patient acuity and case complexity, market share, and prior contracted rates. A well-documented, defensible offer is what wins.

Batching

Qualified similar claims can be combined into one dispute when they share the same payer, similar items or services, and fall within the same time window. That's what makes many smaller underpayments worth pursuing.

After the award

The determination is binding. Payment is generally due within 30 calendar days. A 90-day cooling-off period then generally prevents the initiating party from filing a new dispute against the same party for the same service, though claims from that period can be submitted once it ends.

Deadlines

The federal IDR timeline, step by step

Key deadline: start open negotiation within 30 business days of the initial payment or denial. If it fails, initiate IDR within 4 business days after the 30-business-day negotiation ends.
StepWhat happensTiming
1. EOBInsurer issues initial payment or denialDay 0: the clock starts
2. Open negotiationProvider notifies insurer to negotiateWithin 30 business days of the EOB; lasts 30 business days
3. Initiate IDRDispute filed through the federal IDR portalWithin 4 business days after negotiation ends
4. Entity selectionCMS-certified IDR entity chosen or assignedShortly after initiation
5. Final offersEach side submits one offer with supportGenerally within 10 business days of selection
6. DeterminationArbitrator picks one offerGenerally within 30 business days of selection
7. PaymentAmount owed is paid to the providerGenerally within 30 calendar days of determination

General summary of federal rules; exact deadlines can vary by claim, and agency guidance changes. Have each claim reviewed.

Florida

Florida Statute §408.7057: the state process

Short answer: Florida's statewide claim dispute program lets Florida-licensed providers, including those with claims against HMOs, dispute underpaid claims with a generally 12-month filing window and a usual-and-customary payment standard. It's administered by the Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA) through Capitol Bridge LLC.

Florida HMOs

Florida's HMO statute (§641.3154) generally bars providers from billing HMO members for amounts the HMO owes. That makes the state dispute process the main way to get paid on underpaid HMO claims, and it's a claim type the federal process often doesn't reach.

Texas

Texas SB 1264

Texas created its own mediation and arbitration process for out-of-network claims under state-regulated plans, administered by the Texas Department of Insurance. Self-insured ERISA plans generally fall under the federal process instead. Larry Moskowitz is licensed in Texas as well as Florida.

Side by Side

Federal IDR vs. Florida §408.7057

Federal IDR (No Surprises Act)Florida §408.7057
Who can fileOut-of-network providers for covered servicesFlorida-licensed providers, including HMO claims
ServicesEmergency, air ambulance, out-of-network care at in-network facilitiesClaim payment disputes with Florida health plans
PlansMost group plans incl. self-insured ERISA, individual, FEHBState-regulated plans and HMOs
Filing window30 business days to negotiate, then 4 business days to fileGenerally 12 months
Decision styleBaseball-style: arbitrator picks one offerArbitration with broader payment factors
Payment standardQPA plus additional credible informationUsual and customary rates
Administered byCMS-certified IDR entities (nsa-idr.cms.gov)AHCA / Capitol Bridge LLC
Pick the right forum. Filing federally when Florida law governs, or the reverse, can lead to dismissal with no second chance. Forum is decided claim by claim, before anything is filed.
Outcomes Data

What the numbers show

Federal IDR has strongly favored providers who file. Insurers' opening payments are low, and arbitrators have been picking the provider's offer most of the time.

85%Provider Win Rate*
445%Median Award vs. QPA When Providers Win*
~52%Of Federal Cases Are Emergency Services*
90%+Of Eligible Claims Go Unfiled

*2025 CMS federal IDR data. Radiology is the second most common specialty at roughly 15% of cases. Results vary by provider type, claim volume, documentation and arbitrator. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

The QPA

What is the Qualifying Payment Amount?

Short answer: the QPA is generally the insurer's median contracted in-network rate for the same service in the same area. It sets the patient's cost-sharing, and insurers often use it to justify a low payment.

The QPA is calculated by the insurer from its own contracts, and providers can't see the underlying data. That's why it's so often the reason a claim was underpaid. In federal IDR, the arbitrator considers the QPA alongside other credible information, so a strong case documents why your service was worth more: training, acuity, complexity and market rates.

Get Ready

What you need for a claims analysis

Redact patient identifiers, and don't send confidential information until an engagement is confirmed.

Get a Free Claims Analysis
Glossary

IDR terms, defined

EOB (Explanation of Benefits)
The insurer's statement of what it paid or denied. For federal IDR, the initial payment or denial starts the clock.
QPA (Qualifying Payment Amount)
Generally the insurer's median contracted in-network rate for the same service in the same area.
IDR entity
A CMS-certified independent arbitrator that decides federal payment disputes.
Baseball-style arbitration
Each side submits one final offer; the arbitrator must pick one, with no splitting the difference.
Open negotiation
The required 30-business-day negotiation period before federal IDR can be filed.
Batching
Grouping qualified, similar claims into one federal dispute.
Cooling-off period
A 90-calendar-day period after a federal determination that limits new disputes between the same parties for the same service.
Florida §408.7057
Florida's statewide provider and health plan claim dispute program, run by AHCA through Capitol Bridge LLC.
Usual and customary rate
The payment standard generally used in Florida's process, based on what providers usually charge in the area.
FAQ

Common questions about IDR

Yes. The No Surprises Act gives out-of-network providers a federal arbitration right, called Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR), for covered services such as emergency care, air ambulance, and out-of-network care at in-network facilities. Florida-licensed providers may also use the state process under Florida Statute §408.7057.

You generally must start a 30-business-day open negotiation within 30 business days of the initial payment or denial. If negotiation fails, you have 4 business days after it ends to initiate IDR. Missing either deadline usually makes the underpayment permanent.

Florida's state process generally allows a 12-month filing window, much longer than federal IDR. It covers Florida-licensed providers, including claims against HMOs, and is administered by AHCA through Capitol Bridge LLC.

Filing a federal IDR dispute when Florida law governs the plan, or the reverse, can lead to dismissal, often after the correct deadline has passed. Determining the right forum for each claim is the first step of a review.

The QPA is generally the insurer's median contracted in-network rate for the same service in the same area. A low QPA is often why a claim was underpaid. In federal IDR, the arbitrator weighs the QPA along with other credible information such as provider training and acuity.

Often yes. Federal rules allow qualified similar claims to be batched into one dispute when they involve the same payer, similar items or services, and fall within a defined time window. Batching makes many smaller underpayments worth pursuing.

A federal IDR determination is binding. Payment is generally due within 30 calendar days. If an insurer does not pay, there are complaint and enforcement paths, including through CMS and state regulators.

Yes. Texas SB 1264 created state mediation and arbitration for out-of-network claims under state-regulated plans, administered by the Texas Department of Insurance. Self-insured ERISA plans generally fall under the federal process instead.

Find out which of your claims qualify

Free claims analysis. Pure contingency: the fee applies only to new money recovered, and if nothing is recovered, you owe nothing.

Get a Free Claims Analysis